A successful fundraising campaign is not always about finding more people to buy. Sometimes, the bigger opportunity lies in helping each supporter make a slightly larger purchase. This is where average order value (AOV) becomes an important metric. AOV measures the average amount spent per transaction and can reveal opportunities to increase revenue without necessarily increasing the number of buyers.
For organizations such as schools, sports teams, booster clubs, community groups, and nonprofits, improving AOV can make a meaningful difference. However, encouraging larger purchases requires more than simply asking supporters to buy additional products. Organizations must balance revenue goals with affordability, product demand, fulfillment requirements, and the overall experience for supporters.
A thoughtful strategy can help organizations increase the value of individual transactions while keeping campaigns accessible and worthwhile for the people participating.
Table of Contents
What Is Average Order Value in Fundraising?
Average order value is calculated by dividing total campaign revenue by the number of completed orders.
AOV = Total Revenue ÷ Number of Orders
For example, if a campaign generates $12,000 from 300 orders, its average order value is $40.
Increasing that figure to $45 while maintaining the same number of orders would generate $13,500 in revenue. The organization would therefore raise an additional $1,500 without needing to acquire another buyer.
This does not mean that increasing AOV should replace efforts to attract more supporters. A campaign with a high average transaction but very few participants may still underperform. Instead, AOV should be considered alongside participation rate, total sales, profit, and campaign costs.
The goal is not simply to make every customer spend more. It is to create conditions where supporters can comfortably purchase products that genuinely provide value.
Understand What Influences Order Size
Before changing a fundraising strategy, organizations should understand why some customers naturally place larger orders than others.
Several factors can influence transaction value, including product price, product variety, household size, perceived value, purchasing occasion, seller relationships, campaign duration, and the convenience of ordering.
The type of merchandise also matters. For example, snack-oriented popcorn fundraisers may benefit from multiple-item purchases because customers can buy different flavors for households, events, or sharing. A cookie dough fundraiser can produce larger household orders because customers may purchase several containers for future use.
These examples illustrate an important principle: AOV is influenced by buying behavior, not simply by the number of products offered.
Understanding that behavior allows organizers to design campaigns around genuine customer needs instead of relying on aggressive sales tactics.
Offer Product Bundles With a Clear Purpose
Bundling is one of the most common ways to increase transaction value. Rather than asking customers to add unrelated items, organizations can group complementary products into a package.
A bundle might combine several flavors, multiple quantities, or products intended for a particular occasion. The purpose should be immediately understandable to the customer.
For example, a family-oriented bundle could provide several products at a modest combined discount. An event package could contain enough individual items for a gathering. These approaches give customers a reason to increase their order while simplifying the purchasing decision.
However, bundling has a potential downside. A discount reduces the amount earned per product, meaning higher revenue does not automatically translate into higher profit.
Organizations should therefore calculate the net contribution of a bundle rather than focusing solely on its total selling price.
Use Product Variety Carefully
Offering more choices can encourage customers to purchase additional items. Someone who initially intends to purchase one flavor may add another because the campaign offers several appealing alternatives.
Yet more variety is not always better.
Too many options can make the decision process complicated and increase logistical demands. Organizations may have to manage additional inventory, communicate more product information, and coordinate more complicated order fulfillment.
A smaller selection of well-chosen products can sometimes produce better results than an extensive catalog.
The right balance depends on the audience. A large community campaign may benefit from broader variety, while a smaller organization with limited volunteers may be better served by a focused selection.
Create Multiple Price Points
Another effective approach is to offer products at different price levels. A campaign might include affordable individual purchases alongside larger packages or premium options.
This allows customers to choose according to their budget rather than forcing everyone toward a single spending level.
For instance, a supporter with a limited budget might purchase one inexpensive item, while another customer who wants to support the organization more substantially could select a larger package.
This strategy can increase AOV without making lower-priced products inaccessible.
The important consideration is avoiding an excessive emphasis on expensive options. Fundraising campaigns depend heavily on goodwill, and customers should feel that they are making a voluntary contribution rather than being pressured into spending beyond their means.
Make the Value of Larger Purchases Obvious
Customers are more likely to increase their orders when they understand why doing so benefits them.
Simply displaying a message such as “Buy More” provides little motivation. A stronger approach explains the practical value of purchasing multiple products.
Larger quantities may be useful for families, offices, parties, school events, sports gatherings, or future consumption. If the campaign offers a multi-item package at a reasonable price, the savings or convenience should be clearly communicated.
This is particularly important because fundraising purchases have two dimensions of value: the product itself and the contribution to the organization.
Customers should be able to see both.
Use Campaign Goals to Encourage Participation
Fundraising campaigns can also connect purchasing activity with collective goals.
For example, an organization might establish a campaign target and communicate progress toward it. This creates a shared objective rather than focusing exclusively on individual purchases.
Progress tracking can encourage supporters who were already planning to buy to consider whether an additional item would help the group reach its target.
The challenge is maintaining transparency. Goals should be realistic and clearly communicated. Excessive urgency or repeated pressure can negatively affect the customer experience and potentially reduce long-term willingness to participate.
Make Online Ordering Convenient
Convenience can have a substantial impact on order size.
A complicated ordering process can discourage customers from completing purchases or adding additional products. Conversely, clear product descriptions, straightforward navigation, accessible payment options, and mobile-friendly ordering can make larger purchases easier.
Online campaigns can also make it easier for supporters to review the entire product range before completing an order. This gives organizations an opportunity to present related products or larger packages at appropriate points in the purchasing process.
However, convenience should not be confused with constant upselling.
Additional recommendations should be relevant. A customer who has already selected several products does not necessarily need to see a long series of unrelated offers before checking out.
Train Sellers to Ask Better Questions
In many fundraising campaigns, the person selling the product has considerable influence over order size.
Effective sellers do not need to pressure customers. Instead, they can ask simple questions that help identify genuine opportunities.
For example:
- Is this for your household or an event?
- Would you like to see the other available options?
- Are you purchasing for more than one person?
- Would a larger package be useful?
These questions can uncover legitimate needs that might otherwise go unnoticed.
Seller training should emphasize helpfulness rather than aggressive sales techniques. Short-term increases in order value are less valuable if customers leave the campaign feeling uncomfortable or pressured.
Consider Timing and Purchasing Occasions
The timing of a campaign can affect how much customers are willing to purchase.
A campaign connected to a holiday, sporting event, school activity, community gathering, or seasonal occasion may naturally encourage larger orders because customers have a specific reason to buy.
Organizations should therefore consider whether their products align with the timing of the campaign.
At the same time, seasonal relevance can create limitations. Demand may decline if the campaign continues after the purchasing occasion has passed. Campaign length should be long enough to provide supporters with opportunities to participate but short enough to maintain momentum.
Use Incentives Without Destroying Profitability
Incentives can encourage customers or sellers to increase sales. These might include volume discounts, achievement-based rewards, or campaign milestones.
However, every incentive has a cost.
If an organization gives away too much value in the pursuit of higher sales, its additional revenue may produce little additional profit. A $10 increase in AOV does not necessarily mean $10 more reaches the organization’s cause.
Before introducing an incentive, organizers should calculate product costs, discounts, fulfillment expenses, payment processing fees, and other campaign-related costs.
The most useful incentive is one that increases contribution rather than simply increasing gross sales.
Measure More Than Average Order Value
AOV is useful, but it should never be evaluated in isolation.
Organizations should compare it with metrics such as total revenue, number of orders, participation rate, profit per order, repeat participation, and fulfillment costs.
Imagine Campaign A generates 500 orders at an average of $30, while Campaign B generates 350 orders at an average of $40.
Campaign B has the higher AOV, but Campaign A generates more total revenue:
- Campaign A: 500 × $30 = $15,000
- Campaign B: 350 × $40 = $14,000
If Campaign B also has significantly higher product costs, it may be even less attractive from a profitability perspective.
This demonstrates why increasing AOV should be treated as one component of campaign optimization, rather than the ultimate objective.
Protect the Supporter Experience
Perhaps the most important consideration is the relationship between revenue goals and supporter trust.
Fundraising depends on people choosing to participate. If organizations focus too heavily on maximizing every transaction, they risk making the campaign feel like a conventional sales operation rather than a community-driven effort.
Supporters should have clear information about pricing, products, ordering, delivery, and how their purchases contribute to the organization’s goals.
Larger orders should result from genuine value, convenience, or need—not confusion or pressure.
A campaign that generates slightly less revenue per transaction but creates a positive experience may have greater long-term value because satisfied supporters are more likely to participate in future campaigns.
Build a Sustainable AOV Strategy
Increasing average order value works best when it becomes part of a broader fundraising strategy.
Start by establishing the current AOV and identifying which products, sellers, customer groups, and sales channels produce the largest transactions. Then test one change at a time, such as introducing a bundle, simplifying product choices, improving product descriptions, or offering a useful quantity option.
Track the results against total revenue and profitability.
If AOV increases but participation falls substantially, the strategy may need adjustment. If order size rises while profit margins decline, the organization may need to modify discounts or product combinations. If customers respond positively to bundles, those packages can become a recurring part of future campaigns.
The objective is not to push every supporter toward the largest possible order. It is to make it easier for customers who genuinely want additional products to find useful options.
Ultimately, a strong product fundraising campaign balances customer value, organizational revenue, profitability, convenience, and long-term supporter relationships. By understanding purchasing behavior and measuring the right performance indicators, organizations can increase transaction value without compromising the purpose and trust at the heart of fundraising.
